Which Toyota Tacoma? Buy a 2014 or a 2015?

The Toyota Tacoma ranks among the top compact/midsize pickups. If you’re choosing between a 2014 and a 2015 Tacoma, this quick guide highlights features, reliability, safety, pricing, and pros/cons to help you decide.

Toyota Tacoma model years

2014 Toyota Tacoma — Snapshot

  • Smooth-shifting automatic; standard 5-speed manual on some trims.

  • First-rate cabin build quality; user-friendly standard infotainment (CD, USB, Bluetooth, voice commands).

  • Spacious rear seats in Double Cab; Access Cab rear seats are tighter.

  • Discontinued X-Runner; excellent fuel economy for the class; low long-term ownership costs.

  • Options available: JBL audio, heated fronts, HD Radio, navigation, cruise control.

2014 Pros & Cons

  • Pros: Quality interior, easy infotainment, smooth auto, low ownership costs.

  • Cons: Tight rear seats (Access Cab).

Ranking: #3 in 2014 Compact Pickup Trucks; winner of 2014 Best Compact Truck for the Money. Score: 8.0/10.
Reliability: 3/5 (J.D. Power, average).
Safety: NHTSA overall 4/5.

Typical Price Range (used): ~$15,400 – $25,800 (varies by configuration, mileage, condition, and location).
See 2014 Tacoma deals

2015 Toyota Tacoma — Snapshot

  • Introduces TRD Pro trim; Regular Cab discontinued.

  • Four- and six-cylinder engines; respectable fuel economy.

  • 6.1" touchscreen, CD, USB, Bluetooth, A/C, power windows/locks, cruise, keyless entry, satellite radio, rearview camera; available navigation.

2015 Pros & Cons

  • Pros: Punchy engines, excellent reliability, standout off-road capability (TRD trims).

  • Cons: Firm ride; few advanced safety features for the year.

Ranking: #1 in 2015 Compact Pickup Trucks; finalist for 2015 Best Compact Truck for the Money. Score: 8.7/10.
Reliability: 5/5 (J.D. Power, excellent).
Safety: IIHS “Marginal” in roof strength; NHTSA 4/5 in rollover.

Typical Price Range (used): ~ $19,900 – $31,600 (avg. list about $26,600; varies by condition, mileage, features, location).
See 2015 Tacoma deals

2014 vs 2015 — Key Differences

  • Off-Road: 2015 adds TRD Pro for factory off-road hardware and presence.

  • Reliability: 2015 earns a perfect 5/5 vs. 2014’s average 3/5.

  • Cab Choices: 2015 drops Regular Cab; 2014 still offers it in some configs.

  • Tech & Features: Both have solid, simple infotainment; 2015 standardizes more comfort/convenience across trims.

  • Pricing: 2014s are generally more affordable; 2015s command more due to higher demand, trims, and ratings.

2014 Tacoma

2015 Tacoma

Best For

Value hunters, more cab variety (incl. some Regular Cab), lower entry price

Top reliability, TRD Pro off-road performance, stronger resale

Reliability (J.D. Power)

3/5

5/5

Ranking (U.S. News)

#3 (8.0/10)

#1 (8.7/10)

Safety Highlights

NHTSA overall 4/5

NHTSA rollover 4/5; IIHS Marginal roof strength

Typical Used Price

~$15.4k–$25.8k

~$19.9k–$31.6k (avg. ~$26.6k)

Buying Tips

  • Check history and maintenance: get a vehicle history report (e.g., CarFax) and service records.

  • Test-drive both years if possible—ride firmness and cab space differ by trim and configuration.

  • If off-roading is a priority, look for TRD Off-Road (either year) or TRD Pro (2015).

Bottom Line

  • Choose 2014 if you want a lower purchase price and are satisfied with “average” reliability and features.

  • Choose 2015 if you want top reliability, stronger resale, and access to the TRD Pro package.

Shop & Finance

Sources